What does writing look like to someone who cannot read or write?
The image you see here was created by my three-year-old grandson, Zeke. It is his attempt to make a book.
Zeke is read a lot of picture books by his parents. Moreover, his seven-year-old sister—in first grade—is excited about learning to read and write. So Zeke has a lot of experience with writing, but has virtually no comprehension of how to make sense of it. Even so, here he is attempting to replicate writing—all those squiggly lines.
For those of us who read, who have, more or less, mastered the art of decoding the symbols we refer to as the alphabet, I think it’s hard to grasp what a person sees when they can make no sense of writing. The closest I have come to that—as an adult—occurred when I walked through the streets of Tokyo, passing through a veritable forest of written Japanese of which I could make no sense whatsoever. Still, I knew it was writing and knew, too, it was my ignorance of Japanese that prevented me from reading.
But Zeke doesn’t grasp how our writing works. Nonetheless, he is replicating what he sees. Those squiggly lines.
But even as I write this, things are changing for Zeke. His dad (my son) tells me Zeke recognizes a Z when he sees one. In other words–so to speak–the end of our alphabet is the beginning of reading for him. I’ll miss the squiggles.
6 thoughts on “Squiggly lines”
adorable! he will soon learn
No worries. You have many years of squiggles, attempted letters, and inventive spelling ahead of you. And then you can enjoy the traditionally written masterpieces as well!
I love Zeke’s story. It’s funny to think about it, though, because, as you said, he is replicating what he sees.
Which really makes the amount of pain and suffering books put me through sound completely ridiculous from this distance.
So sweet. So true. My almost 3 yo is just entering this phase. What a wonder it is!
Hello! My name is Elle and My friend Brittany. We are 11 years old. That is just adorable what your grand sun has made! I wish I was as talented as him! 🙂 Are you teaching him how to write just like you, the amazing talented writer? How did you over come your Dysgraphia?
I have been a believer for 45 years of teaching (because it’s been proven over and over) that children write before they read. Did you ask Zeke to tell you his story?