word craft


Goodbye Christopher Robin

Goodbye Christopher Robin

I recent­ly watched (on TV) Good­bye Christo­pher Robin, which tells the life sto­ry of the boy so key to Win­nie-the-Pooh, by A.A. Milne. Accord­ing to the movie, Pooh is the “most loved children’s book of all time.”

The depict­ed sto­ry of the boy’s life is a painful one. A.A. Milne, (Christopher’s father) played by Domh­nall Gleeso, was a vet­er­an of World War One, and suf­fered from PTSD syn­drome, which caused him—a very suc­cess­ful West End playwright—to suf­fer debil­i­tat­ing war-induced flashbacks—to have a repressed emo­tion­al life—and a hard time being an engaged father.

Christopher’s moth­er (played by Mar­got Rob­bie) is depict­ed as self­ish, exploita­tive of her son’s fame, and a snob­bish upper-class lady.

The most con­sis­tent love in Christopher’s life comes from his Irish nan­ny (played by Kel­ly Macdonald)—who is dis­missed when she objects to the way Christo­pher is mistreated.

The very young Christo­pher Robin is played, charm­ing­ly, by Will Tilston.

The movie sug­gests that the Pooh sto­ries came to life when Christo­pher and his father enjoy a rare time alone togeth­er in rur­al Eng­land. Moth­er has left for Lon­don to enjoy the high life, while the nan­ny has gone away to take care of her dying moth­er. In oth­er words, get rid of the women, and cre­ativ­i­ty happens.

But the essen­tial sto­ry revealed here is the deep resent­ment Christo­pher felt as to how he was exploit­ed, and cheat­ed of parental love. As depict­ed, he spent much of his young adult life try­ing to get away from his lit­er­ary persona.

What does the film tell us about Win­nie-the-Pooh? Very lit­tle except to sug­gest how some of the book’s charm­ing points came from some of the rare moments when father and son enjoyed time together.

a scene from Goodbye Christopher Robin
Scene from Good­bye Christo­pher Robin [Fox Searchlight]

What does the film tell us about children’s lit­er­a­ture, or the writ­ing life? Nothing.

What does the film tell us about ear­ly 20th Cen­tu­ry British par­ent­ing? That it was pret­ty pathetic.

At the end of the movie we are told (via sub­ti­tles) that Christo­pher refused to take a pen­ny of the mas­sive mon­ey engen­dered by Pooh, that he always remained in con­tact with his for­mer nan­ny, and that he cre­at­ed and ran a bookstore.

I liked that part.

But it also sug­gests that a book—however depen­dent on the real­i­ties of an author’s life—that life has lit­tle to do with how read­ers enjoy it. It is fas­ci­nat­ing to think how lit­tle a writer has to do with the pub­lished book once it is the hands of readers.

Indeed, when it comes to books, it’s the read­ers who mat­ter most.

4 thoughts on “<em>Goodbye Christopher Robin</em>”

  1. A rather sad movie, it seems. I haven’t seen it yet. I always hope that the writ­ers of beau­ti­ful, hon­or­able chil­dren’s book are also beau­ti­ful of soul and hon­or­able. Sad­ly, too often I have found it not so…still there are some who write as they are.

  2. Dear Avi,
    I’ve read your books since I was a lit­tle girl in ele­men­tary, just learn­ing about what the world was and how to read. I’d like to say that I deeply appre­ci­ate all that you’ve writ­ten, that it’s helped shape who I am today, and that I will always car­ry your words around with me. I hope you don’t mind too much, for I think they are good words and I val­ue them. Thank you for being here for so many peo­ple, includ­ing me.

  3. I enjoyed the movie, gave me time to pause. Your com­ments have also giv­en me time to reflect, Avi. Thank you.

  4. I love your wise analy­sis and con­clu­sion. Books live in read­ers’ minds. With­out writ­ers, this can’t hap­pen. Louise Rosen­blatt so wise­ly talked about this. A writer writes from their own voice and luck­i­ly sends it out into the world. Thank you, writers!


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Recent Posts