word craft


A Computer Screen is Not a Book

On my doorstep, the oth­er day land­ed (with an actu­al thud) an ARC (Advanced Read­ers Copy) of my new book, Loy­al­ty.  When I receive such vol­umes, it is always very spe­cial because the man­u­script that I have been work­ing on for so long—spinning a cocoon, so to speak—has turned out a butterfly—a book. 

It looks dif­fer­ent, it feels dif­fer­ent, and most fas­ci­nat­ing to me, it reads dif­fer­ent­ly. I’m not alto­geth­er sure why this is so. Per­haps it is no more than the deeply embed­ded psy­chol­o­gy I have devel­oped from a life­time of read­ing actu­al books. These days—and for years now—I com­pose on a com­put­er, but a com­put­er screen is not a book. I find it hard to read a full-length book straight through on a com­put­er.  At a cer­tain point, I must always print pages and work with words on paper. 

e-book reading

As for read­ing on an e‑reader, I always feel like I am walk­ing on a slimy sur­face. My eyes seem to slide around the back-lit page. 

(I think it is against the laws of God and man for a page to shine up at me. My read­ing light should shine down onto the page.) 

With an e‑book I find myself gloss­ing over words, para­graphs, whole pages. God help me if I tap the rud­dy thing the wrong way. I’m nev­er quite sure where I am. Maybe because it inevitably puts me to sleep. 

Is this just me? My age? My habits of read­ing? Do mil­len­ni­als have this prob­lem? Am I a Lud­dite? [OED: “One who oppos­es the intro­duc­tion of new tech­nol­o­gy, esp. into a place of work.”] 

Because when I read a real book I always know where I am. Moreover—explain this to me—the work achieves a whole­ness, an inher­ent log­ic (or lack of) that gives a bet­ter sense of the qual­i­ties of the writ­ing, or, for that mat­ter, its weaknesses. 

Sure­ly some edu­ca­tion doc­tor­al can­di­date has stud­ied how read­ers react dif­fer­ent­ly (if they do) to print­ed text and pix­el text. Do we absorb more? Remem­ber more? Learn more in one for­mat or the oth­er? If so, some­one please tell me. To echo Patrick Hen­ry, I know not what course oth­ers may take, but as for me, give me print over pix­els any day. 

So, hav­ing received the ARC of Loy­al­ty, I was able to spend a whole day read­ing through my 335-page work—curiously enough—the first time I was able to do so. I start­ed at about nine AM and fin­ished it around nine PM. While it may seem odd to say so, I was able to enjoy the text and was much relieved that it held togeth­er with the kind of sus­pense I enjoy writ­ing. “Bet­ter than I had thought it was,” I told my wife when I put it down. “It works just fine.” I felt great relief. 

I had writ­ten a book. 

5 thoughts on “A Computer Screen is Not a Book”

  1. I love your posts. Have read them for years. This is truth in my world.
    Thank you, Avi
    Gillian Foster

  2. Yes. Hard to read real­ly good work on a device. I have in a pinch read on my actu­al phone via Kin­dle read­er. Not ide­al, but I will do that if I must. i don’t like the Kin­dle I bought at all. Too dim a screen. I love a good book.…everything about a book, good or not mat­ters to me. I want to snug­gle up to it and let it wrap its arms around me. So this does speak to me. Janet F

  3. I can think of few tech­nolo­gies more per­fect than the bound book. Those dig­i­tal abom­i­na­tions do not and can­not ever “enhance” or “improve” upon the expe­ri­ence of read­ing words on paper.

  4. There appears to be quite a body of sci­en­tif­ic lit­er­a­ture on the top­ic. The most famous paper, Man­gen 2013 (“Read­ing lin­ear texts on paper ver­sus com­put­er screen: Effects on read­ing com­pre­hen­sion”; https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijer.2012.12.002), agrees with your observations.

  5. I used to chuck my strong pref­er­ence for paper books to age and con­di­tion­ing. But my kids (gen­er­a­tion Z) much pre­fer paper books.
    Screens are use­ful to skim the news. Good fic­tion is best served with the light shin­ing on it, not from behind it.


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Recent Posts