word craft


Story Behind the Story #47: The Book Without Words

The Book Without WordsWhen the phone call came telling me that I had won the New­bery award for Crispin: The Cross of Lead, tru­ly, my very first thought was, The next book had bet­ter be good.

How to explain? It’s my expe­ri­ence that writ­ers, despite an out­ward appear­ance of cheer­ful belief in their own tal­ent, are quite often, in fact, inse­cure. It’s not hard to explain why: you sit alone and work for long peri­ods of time on a project. You are con­stant­ly think­ing, is this right? Is this any good? Will any­one like it? As one of my ear­ly men­tors told me: “To be a suc­cess­ful writer, you have go to bed think­ing what you’ve writ­ten is ter­rif­ic, as long as when you get up in the morn­ing you know how bad it is. To reverse the process is to go mad.”

And there is anoth­er lev­el of inse­cu­ri­ty. Win an award and the inter­nal (and eter­nal) ques­tion is inevitably, can I do that again? The painful truth is, prob­a­bly not. When a very young writer wins a major award, I tru­ly feel sor­ry for them. They may well be chas­ing that award for the rest of their writ­ing lives.

Hence my reac­tion to the New­bery award: The next book had bet­ter be good.

The next book I wrote was The Book With­out Words and, indeed, it proved one of the most dif­fi­cult books I have ever writ­ten. That was me chas­ing the award, want­i­ng so much to make it good.

That said, the book was well received, and enjoyed a recep­tion such as this Ama­zon post­ing: “This book has every­thing in it that my daugh­ter loves and she trea­sures this book! She orig­i­nal­ly got this book at the book fair when she was younger and it got mis­placed. She was ecsta­t­ic when I gave it to her to replace the one she lost years ago.”

The sto­ry, a medieval fan­ta­sy, deals with mag­ic and alche­my. The title comes from a medieval book, an absolute­ly blank book. Magi­cians would claim they could read the book, and bring forth spirits.

Not alto­geth­er dif­fer­ent, I once heard the poet Don­ald Hall explain what makes for good writ­ing:  “A good writer writes, as it were, some­thing shaped like the let­ter C. If the gap is too great, the read­er can­not fill it. If it is too small, there is no rea­son for the read­er to fill it. But if that gap is just right, the read­er fills it with their own expe­ri­ence and the writ­ing is complete. ”

It is rather like the proverb quot­ed in the begin­ning of The Book With­out Words: “A life unlived is like a book with­out words.”

1 thought on “Story Behind the Story #47: The Book Without Words”

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Recent Posts