Avi

word craft

blog

A Moving Target

a moving target

If some­one asks me what I do and I reply, “I am a writer of books,” it is almost uni­ver­sal­ly under­stood what I mean. So when I answer that way, the next ques­tion is almost always, “What kind of books do you write?”

I’ll say, “I write books for young people.”

“Oh, that’s fun.”

As in, “That’s easy.”

In our edu­ca­tion­al cul­ture, read­ing and writ­ing are almost uni­ver­sal­ly taught. I think there is an expec­ta­tion that every­one can do so, though that is far from the case. Regard­less, if one also accepts the notion (I do) that writ­ing is an art, it is the only art that is pret­ty much uni­ver­sal­ly taught. Music isn’t. Draw­ing isn’t. Singing and danc­ing aren’t. Sculp­ture isn’t. I believe they should be, but aren’t.

Writ­ing, how­ev­er, is.

To be sure, writ­ing is not taught as an art, but pri­mar­i­ly as a basic nec­es­sary social skill. “You need it to get along.” 

But, if you also believe, as I do, that a con­sid­er­able part of writ­ing is read­ing, and that the skill of read­ing is taught less and less, we have a prob­lem with writing.

Let me put it metaphor­i­cal­ly. If I am going to teach some­one to play base­ball, I prob­a­bly would begin by giv­ing instruc­tions on how to throw a ball. But if there is no one to catch the ball, it’s a pret­ty mean­ing­less exer­cise. So it is when you write (throw­ing the ball) you are expect­ing some­one to read what you have writ­ten (catch­ing the ball).

To be sure, the art of writ­ing goes far beyond a sim­ple game of throw and catch. When you are writ­ing, you are shar­ing depic­tions of exis­tence, ideas, emo­tions, rela­tion­ships, and a whole lot beyond. Just to begin, you require a vocab­u­lary so that you can name all those things. Remem­ber, in the Gar­den of Eden, Adam began explor­ing his new world by nam­ing things. Like­wise, watch an infant attempt to describe, vent, or express some­thing deeply felt with a lim­it­ed word choice. It can pro­mote frus­tra­tion to the lev­el of tantrums.

The big dif­fer­ence between writ­ing for adults and writ­ing for young peo­ple is that the young do not have a ful­ly devel­oped vocab­u­lary, nor the expe­ri­ences to put in con­text all the words one uses in por­tray­ing a big­ger world.

Writ­ing for young peo­ple (to go back to my metaphor) involves the writer throw­ing that ball to dif­fer­ent young peo­ple who are mov­ing about to dif­fer­ent places at ran­dom. But as a writer, you are also throw­ing the ball from your one hand to your oth­er. Which is to say a writer writes and reads simultaneously.

I think you can write about any­thing for young peo­ple, but to be suc­cess­ful at it, you must do it in a way that makes sense to the young per­son. Of course, there is no uni­ver­sal “young per­son.” Each child is unique in terms of their vocab­u­lary and expe­ri­ence. A mov­ing tar­get, if ever there was one. But oh, such a wor­thy one!

Is writ­ing for young peo­ple fun?

Some­times.

Most­ly it’s hard.

But I still like trying.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.