word craft


Advice and criticism always help

Dur­ing this past sum­mer, I invit­ed a num­ber of very accom­plished writ­ers to share a book about writ­ing that they have found par­tic­u­lar­ly mean­ing­ful and use­ful. It has fas­ci­nat­ed me that with two excep­tions (Forster’s Aspects of the Nov­el and Goldberg’s Writ­ing Down the Bones) dif­fer­ent books have been cit­ed. (The 14 arti­cles in the 2023 Sum­mer Blog Series begin here.)

I sus­pect we all know there is no one way to write, and that every writer needs to find her/his way to work and cre­ate sto­ries. This list of rec­om­mend­ed titles by fine writ­ers proves that. 

Yes, it would be most instruc­tive to go through all these books and see what they have in com­mon. It would be a huge, time-con­sum­ing task, which, I has­ten to say, I have no inten­tion of doing. Be my guest. 

There is, more­over, that old cliché, “The proof of the pud­ding is in the eat­ing.” This has been defined as “the real val­ue of some­thing can be judged only from prac­ti­cal expe­ri­ence or results and not from appear­ance or theory.” 

So for all you writ­ers (and readers)—including myself—may I sug­gest, if your writ­ing works, it works. But—my expe­ri­ence is that advice and crit­i­cism always help. 

Here are the books cited. 

Aspects of the Nov­el. E.M. Forster 

Becom­ing a Writer. Dorothea Brande 

Bird by Bird. Anne Lamott

Land of the Dead. Bri­an McDon­ald and Toby Cypress 

Save the Cat Writes a Nov­el. Jes­si­ca Brody

The Secrets of Sto­ry. Matt Bird 

The Sound on the Page. Ben Yagoda 

Sto­ry. Robert McKee 

A Swim in the Pond in the Rain. George Saunders

The Writer’s Jour­ney: Myth­ic Struc­ture for Writ­ers. Christo­pher Vogler

Writ­ing Down the Bones. Natal­ie Gold­berg (2)

Writ­ing Fic­tion. Janet Bur­roway and Eliz­a­beth Stucky-French 

Writ­ing for Sto­ry. Jon Franklin 

Writ­ing with Pic­tures. Uri Shulevitz

(Click on a cov­er to read the arti­cle by the author who chose that book.)

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Recent Posts